It is claimed that the vegan diet has strong evidence behind it. It is said that it can make people lose weight and even reverse killer diseases. However… vegan proponents usually don’t tell you the full story. They make it seem like there is overwhelming evidence in favor of the vegan diet. But in reality, this evidence is weak and there is a large body of evidence that they are ignoring. The truth is, vegan diets can work… at least for some people. There are also some ethical and environmental arguments to be made for avoiding animal foods (even though I personally don’t agree with them). But many vegan advocates are incredibly dishonest about animal foods and spread unscientific fear mongering to convince people that their diet is healthy. Here are 7 common myths about vegan diets.
1. The Health Benefits of Vegan Diets Are Due to Avoiding Animal Foods
There are a number of studies showing health benefits of vegan and vegetarian diets (1).
The proponents of such diets like to attribute these health benefits to the avoidance of animal foods.
However, there are many other factors at play.
A properly planned vegan diet consists primarily of whole foods. It is often called a Whole-Foods, Plant-Based (WFPB) diet.
This diet doesn’t just eliminate animal foods… it also eliminates a number of foods that science has shown to be harmful.
What else do they remove, besides animal foods? Let’s have a look…
- Refined sugar: Causes insulin resistance and fatty liver. Strong links to obesity, diabetes and heart disease (2, 3, 4, 5, 6).
- Refined grains: Lead to rapid spikes in blood sugar, insulin resistance and weight gain. Strong links to many chronic, Western diseases (7, 8, 9).
- Vegetable Oils: High in inflammatory Omega-6 fatty acids, increase inflammation and oxidative damage (10, 11, 12).
- Trans Fats: Extremely harmful, man-made fats found in processed foods and linked to many serious diseases, especially heart disease (13, 14).
Not to mention that these diets also eliminate processed foods… which are low in nutrients and high in harmful ingredients and artificial chemicals.
I personally find it plausible that the benefits of vegan diets are largely caused by avoiding processed foods and harmful ingredients like added sugar. It has absolutely nothing to do with avoiding unprocessed animal foods.
In the studies on vegan diets, they usually compare against the junk food-laden Western diet, NOT a whole foods based diet like paleo or the Mediterranean diet.
Bottom Line: The health benefits of vegan diets are likely caused by the elimination of harmful ingredients and processed foods. It has nothing to do with avoiding unprocessed animal foods.
2. Saturated Fat and Cholesterol Are Harmful Substances
The myth that animal fats cause heart disease still runs rampant among vegans.
In the past few years and decades, studies have shown this to be false… and experts all over the world are changing their minds.
Saturated fat and cholesterol actually lead to improvements in the blood cholesterol profile. They don’t make things worse, like previously believed (15).
A massive review study that looked at data from 21 other studies with a total of 347,747 participants concluded: There is absolutely no association between saturated fat consumption and heart disease (24).
Now… some vegan proponents may say that these studies shouldn’t be trusted because they’re funded by the meat, egg or dairy industries, but that is nonsense.
This has been studied intensely and it is NOT true that most of the studies are industry sponsored.
The truth is, saturated fat and cholesterol were wrongly demonized. The highest quality studies show them to be completely harmless for the majority of people.
Bottom Line: The myth that saturated fat and cholesterol lead to heart disease still runs rampant among vegans, but this myth has been thoroughly debunked in the past few years and decades.
3. A Vegan Diet is The Only Diet Proven to Reverse Heart Disease
It is often claimed that vegan diets are the only diet proven to reverse heart disease.
This idea is based on a number of studies by two doctors, Dean Ornish and Caldwell Esselstyn.
This goes beyond just biomarkers like cholesterol. They managed to partly reverse coronary heart disease. Impressive stuff, I’ll give them that.
However, I don’t think anything can be concluded about the vegan diet based on these studies. Let me explain why…
Ornish’s approach involves a lifestyle intervention. His patients also exercise, quit smoking and do meditation… along with other health promoting things. His diet was also not a vegan diet, but a low-fat vegetarian diet (28).
It is very clear that studies that use drugs or exercise (massive confounders) along with a diet can NOT be used to make claims about the diet.
In order to attribute the benefits of the intervention to the diet, then you need to isolate diet as the only variable that is different between groups.
Bottom Line: There are some studies showing a low-fat vegan/vegetarian diet to reverse coronary heart disease. However, these studies also used drugs or health promoting things like exercise and meditation.
4. The China Study
In almost every argument about vegan diets or animal foods, someone brings up The China Study.
This is a book that was written by biochemist and nutrition researcher T. Colin Campbell.
The book makes a case for animal foods (animal protein, in particular) being the main driver of killer diseases like heart disease and cancer.
The case is loosely supported with data from a massive epidemiological study called The China-Cornell-Oxford Project, along with a number of other observations and studies on rats.
Then he uses confusing terminology to make it seem like the rat studies using isolated proteins like casein have anything to do with diet and cancer in humans.
The book has been criticized by a number of people who have analyzed the findings:
- Dr. Chris Masterjohn: What Dr. Campbell Won’t Tell You About The China Study
- Denise Minger: The China Study – Fact or Fallacy
- Dr. Michael Eades: The China Study vs the China study
The findings of The China Study have also been contradicted by various other studies, some of which are of a much higher methodological quality.
This includes a recent study from Asia… a study with 112,310 men and 184,411 women, showing that red meat consumption was associated with reduced risk of heart disease in men and reduced risk of cancer in women (30).
The China Study is NOT about nutrition science. It belongs in the science fiction section of the library.
Bottom Line: The China Study has been thoroughly debunked by objective scientists and there are multiple high quality studies that contradict its findings, all of which were ignored by the author.
5. Animal Protein is Harmful
It is often claimed by vegans that animal protein causes harm.
A lot of this is based on studies in rats, using isolated proteins and refined diets.
The results of rodent studies using highly unnatural and refined diets aren’t necessarily applicable to humans.
In many cases, human studies on diet end up leading to the exact opposite results of the rodent studies. This appears to be the case with animal protein.
In fact, almost every human controlled trial on protein, both animal and plant protein, shows it to be beneficial for health.
The evidence is mounting that most people should be eating more animal protein, not less (42).
Bottom Line: Despite the myth that animal protein causes harm, studies show that it leads to health benefits. This includes weight loss, improved bone health, lower blood pressure and reduced symptoms of diabetes
6. Humans Are Not “Designed” to Eat Animals
Some vegans claim that humans are naturally herbivores and that our bodies are not adapted to eating animals.
Our bodies are well adapted to meat consumption and we are perfectly capable of making full use of the nutrients found in meat.
In fact, our digestive systems don’t resemble those of herbivores at all.
We have short colons, long small intestines and plenty of hydrochloric acid in the stomach to help break down animal protein.
Also, the lengths of different parts of our digestive systems are somewhere in between the lengths typical for carnivores and herbivores, indicating that we are naturally “designed” to be omnivores (45).
The fact that vegans can’t function without B12 supplements or B12 supplemental foods is also a pretty strong argument for these diets not being “natural.”
Also, hunter-gatherers ate lots of meat. Our genes were shaped in an environment that included plenty of animal products (47).
The truth is… humans function best eating both animals and plants. Period.
Bottom Line: Humans are naturally omnivores and function best eating a combination of animals and plants. This is reflected in the anatomy of our digestive system.
7. Meat Causes Heart Disease, Diabetes and Cancer
Most chronic, Western diseases are relatively new.
The heart disease epidemic started around 1930, while type 2 diabetes started increasing rapidly in the late 20th century.
Cancer has also been on the rise for many decades.
Vegans like to blame meat and animal foods for these health problems.
However… meat is an old food and these health problems are relatively new.
Blaming new health problems on old foods makes absolutely no sense.
Let’s take a look at the health problems that meat is being blamed for and the highest quality evidence that examines these claims.
The cancer link is probably related to the way meat is cooked. Several studies suggest that it forms carcinogens when overheated, so it is important to use gentler cooking methods and avoid burning your meat (52).
Keep in mind that all of these studies found a significantly increased risk for people who consumed processed meat. Therefore, differentiating between the different types of meat is important.
It is well known that processed foods in general are harmful… this is not exclusive to meat.
Bottom Line: Studies that differentiate between processed and unprocessed meat show that unprocessed red meat is not associated with heart disease or diabetes, and only weakly linked to cancer in men, but not women.
Original article here